Home · Tibetan culture in Sichuan · Faces in the Dark

Faces in the Dark

A field guide to what is standing in a Tibetan temple: who each figure is, how to tell one from another, and what a Chinese hall does differently. Two parts — the building first, then the statues — because you meet them in that order. Everything here is drawn, not photographed.

手印、持物、身色、坐姿、头饰
Five slots, filled in the same order in Lhasa, in Kathmandu and in a chapel in Chengdu. Read the slots and the name follows.
The figures in this booklet are my own line drawings. They are diagrams: proportions simplified, colour coded to convention, no attempt at likeness. Nothing here is reproduced from a photograph.
4
schools, and where they differ
16
figures you will meet everywhere
18
arhats, or 16 — it depends
Part One  ·  建筑
Guest notes  ·  thirteen

Gate, Courtyard,
Dark Room

门 · 院 · 暗室
How a Tibetan monastery is laid out — and why you walk from full sunlight into a room with no windows.
Almost everything worth seeing in a Tibetan monastery is in one of two rooms: the vestibule where you meet the guardians, and the hall where the buddha sits. This is a guide to the order they come in, and to what is on the tables.
“You are not walking through a building.
You are walking into a darker room, twice.”
你不会一次走进大殿 — 你要先暗一次,再暗一次。
4
spaces between the street and the image
0
windows in the room where the protector lives
8
kinds of offering on the average altar
01  —  The whole route

A route, not a room

A Tibetan monastery is not a single hall that you visit. It is a courtyard with a hall at one end, and the hall is two rooms deep before you reach the image. The route runs from full daylight to no light at all — and that sequence is the first thing the building teaches, before a single word is spoken.
1
Outside A whitewashed wall, one gate, a threshold worn into a hollow. From the street you can hear the yard and see none of it. Nothing has prepared you for the scale of what is behind.
2
The courtyard Full sun, and the loudest part of the monastery: a tap running, a dog asleep against a wall, monks crossing at an angle, someone's motorbike parked in the shade. Three sides of this yard are rooms you will never enter.
3
The first room Low ceiling, cool air, and your eyes have not adjusted. This is the vestibule, and it is deliberately unimpressive: benches, a notice board, a box for money. Its walls do the introduction — guardians on both sides, and a painted wheel by the door.
4
The hall Higher, wider, and darker than the room you came from. Columns wrapped in cloth, thangkas down both walls, one lantern in the roof and one shaft of light on the floor. The buddha is at the far end, and the far end is black.
02  —  The plan

The courtyard does the work

Almost every Tibetan monastery you will enter is a version of one plan: a yard, a hall on the side facing the gate, and buildings around the other three sides. The hall may be the size of a church or the size of a classroom. The yard is always there, and it is always the thing that holds the place together.
1The gate. One opening in a blank wall, usually the only one in use. The threshold is a heavy timber beam, not a painted line: you step over it, you do not stand on it.
2The courtyard. Paved or packed earth, and nothing planted in the middle of it. This is a work surface, not a garden: processions, drying grain, parking, the whole monastery's traffic.
3The vestibule. A shallow room open to the yard, with a row of columns along the front. Formally it is part of the hall; in practice it is a porch, and in winter it is the coldest place in the building.
4The assembly hall. The big room. Rows of low seats on strips of carpet, columns down both sides, and the whole monk body in here at dawn.
5The shrine. Behind the hall, often behind a screen or a railing. The main image lives here, and this is the one part of the building that is not for you.
6The monks' quarters. Long and low, one room to a monk or to a group of monks from the same district. Doors face the yard; washing hangs over the railings.
7The offices. Administration: the management committee, the accounts, guest registration. In a small monastery this is one room with a kettle in it.
8The debating yard. Sometimes a separate walled court, sometimes just a corner of the main one, with trees for shade. Monks debate standing, clapping, and sitting down hard.

Why a courtyard and not a hall. The plan is not Chinese and not Indian: it is a defended house. High blank walls outside, every window facing in, one gate. In a country where monasteries were also fortresses, the yard was the only open ground that could be watched, and the buildings around it were the wall.

What that does to a visitor. You spend the first minutes outdoors in a space with no focal point, and the one thing you are looking for — the great hall — is the least decorated facade in the compound. The building does not advertise. It waits for you to walk towards it.

03  —  The other three sides

The side you walk past

The three sides of the yard that are not the hall are the monastery's actual life, and they are the part most visitors photograph by accident. None of them is a monument. All of them are rooms with a job.
WhereWhat it is What you will actually see
Monks' quarters One room per monk, or per small group from the same home district. Cooking, sleeping, studying and receiving guests all happen in the same 12 square metres. Doors open onto the yard, a bucket by each door, robes drying on a line, a thermos on the step.
The kitchen Often the largest room after the hall. Enormous cauldrons for butter tea, fired with wood or yak dung, feeding several hundred people at dawn. Steam at the door, soot on the beams, a queue of monks with flasks.
The offices The management committee, the accounts, the safe, and the register of visitors. This is where a monastery meets the state and the tax office. A desk, a filing cabinet, a photocopier, a framed photograph of somebody important.
The printing house In the larger monasteries, a workshop where scriptures are still printed from hand-cut wooden blocks, ink rubbed on with a padded roller. Stacks of blocks drying on racks, black ink on everything, paper hanging like laundry.
The debating ground An open court, usually with trees, where monks argue doctrine in pairs — one seated, one standing, the standing one clapping to close an argument. Loud, physical, cheerful; nothing like a lecture, and nothing like prayer.
The guest rooms Most monasteries that receive pilgrims have a row of rooms to let, sometimes run by the monastery, sometimes by a family. This is where you stay if you are here for a festival. A numbered door, a thermos of hot water, an electric blanket, a lock that does not work.
The lama's house The labrang, the residence of a reincarnate lama — often a separate walled compound with its own chapel, and in the great monasteries a power centre of its own. A better-painted door than the rest, sometimes a locked gate, sometimes a car.

The rule of thumb. If a building's door faces the yard, it is for the people who live here. If a building's door faces away from the yard, it is a chapel, and it probably belongs to one family, one college, or one protector.

Where the money comes from. The offices and the printing house are why a Tibetan monastery is not only a place of worship. Most of them run on land, rent, printing, and the steady traffic of pilgrims — and the yard is where all of that is counted.

04  —  The vestibule

The first room is a filter

You do not walk from the yard into the presence of a buddha. You walk into a room that is too low, too dark, and too full of furniture to be impressive — and you stand in it for a while, because your eyes have to adjust. That delay is the room's whole job.
The vestibule in plan. You come in at the bottom; the hall is through the curtain at the top.
1The four kings, left. Painted, not sculpted, and painted at eye level on the side wall so that you meet them sideways as you come in.
2And two more, further in. Two kings on each side wall, facing each other across the room. In a small monastery they may be prints behind glass.
3The wheel. The wheel of existence, at the inner end of the wall, at the height of a standing person's chest. You have to turn your head to read it.
4The door to the hall. A heavy curtain rather than a door leaf. Push it aside with the back of your hand, not your shoulder.
5The bench. Against the far wall, worn smooth. This is where the old people who have walked up from the village sit and rest before going in.
6The shoes. A heap at one side of the door, not a rack. Boots with mud on them, and a pair of good shoes somebody is worried about.

Everything in here is a warning label. The kings are the four directions, which is to say: the whole world. The wheel is the six states you can be born into, which is to say: your options. Between them they cover the two things a first-time visitor needs to know — that this is not a place you have entered casually, and that it is not about you.

What else is in the room. A notice board with photographs of recently deceased monks. A locked donation box with a slot worn shiny. A row of hats on a nail. The vestibule is the only room in the monastery where ordinary daily business is allowed to happen, and it is the only one where you are meant to loiter.

Why it is so low. The whole building is timber and stone with no arch, so a wide span needs a low ceiling. But the effect is the point: you come in from a bright yard and stand under a beam, and by the time your eyes have adjusted you have already slowed down.

05  —  The guardians

Four kings at the door

The four are not buddhas and not saints. They are kings of the four quarters of the world, borrowed from Indian cosmology and dressed as Chinese generals, and each one holds the object that explains his job. In a Tibetan monastery they are usually painted; in a Chinese one they are usually sculpted, and they stand in a hall of their own.
Dhritarashtra
持国 · east
White. A lute. He keeps the music going — which is to say, harmony.
Virudhaka
增长 · south
Blue. A sword. Increase: crops, wealth, descendants, and the strength to defend them.
Virupaksha
广目 · west
Red. A serpent. The name means wide-eyed, and the snake is what he watches.
Vaishravana
多闻 · north
Yellow. An umbrella and a mongoose that spits jewels. The only one of the four with a cult of his own.

The one to remember. Vaishravana, the northern king, is also the god of wealth, and in Tibetan monasteries he has often been promoted out of the vestibule into a chapel of his own. If you see a fat yellow figure with a mongoose, that is him — and the mongoose is not a pet. In the story it was a creature that hoarded treasure, and he made it give the treasure away.

Why four. The set is a map, not a team. East, south, west, north: the kings are the directions personified, and wherever you enter the building you enter from one of them.

Why they look Chinese. The iconography came from India; the costume did not. Armour, boots, a general's belt and a scowling face — by the time the four reached Tibet they had been officers of a Chinese army for a very long time, and that is how they were painted.

The one big difference from a Chinese temple. A Chinese temple gives the four kings a hall of their own, and puts a fat laughing buddha in the middle of it, facing the door. A Tibetan monastery does not. Here the four are paintings on the wall of a passage, and the fat figure — the tenth-century monk Budai — either is not there at all or appears somewhere else entirely.

What to look at. Not the faces. The hands. Four objects, four jobs, and you can read the whole set from the doorway in about ten seconds. That is exactly how they were designed to be read.

Where to stand. In the doorway itself, not the middle of the room. From there you get all four at once, the wheel straight ahead, and the order reads the way it was meant to: the directions, then the states you can be reborn into, then the hall.

06  —  The wheel

The wheel by the door

The second painting in the first room is a circle inside a circle inside a circle, and it is the only diagram in the building. It is not hung where people sit to learn. It is hung where people stand and wait, slightly bored, next to the shoes.
1The outer ring, twelve panels. The twelve links of dependent origination, running from a blind man with a stick — ignorance, the first link — round to old age and death. Each panel is a small scene, and the sequence is a clock.
2The middle ring, six panels. The six states of existence: gods, titans, humans, animals, hungry ghosts, and the hells. Every one of them is temporary. That is the entire point of the drawing.
3The hub, three animals. A cock, a snake, and a pig, each biting the tail of the next: greed, hatred, and delusion, which is what keeps the wheel turning.
4The hands outside. The whole circle is held in the arms of a large figure — time, or death. The wheel does not turn by itself.
5The figure in the corner. A buddha, standing outside the circle, pointing at it. He is not in the wheel. That is the offer.
The one thing the wheel does not show. There is no panel for release. Every state in the circle is temporary, and none of them is the end — which is why the buddha is drawn outside it, in the corner, with one hand raised. The diagram is complete on purpose, and it is a closed loop on purpose.

Why it is at the door. Because it is a claim about you, made before you have agreed to anything. You are in one of those six panels right now, the painting says, and the panel is not permanent. The guardians at the sides are a warning; this is the argument.

Why a circle. Not decoration. A circle is the one shape with no first panel: wherever you start reading, something came before you. A list would let you start at the top, and the whole point is that you cannot.

How to read it in ten seconds. Find the buddha in the corner. Follow his hand to the circle. Then find the panel that looks most like your own life. That is where you are meant to start, and every monk in the building knows it.

The twelve panels, in order. Ignorance, impulse, consciousness, name and form, the senses, contact, feeling, craving, grasping, becoming, birth, and finally old age and death — a chain in which each link makes the next one unavoidable.

07  —  The hall

Where the buddha sits

The hall is a box with a high roof and almost no windows on the outside. Everything you can see in it was made to be seen by lamplight: the cloth on the columns, the paintings on the walls, the gold on the face. The one opening in the roof does not light the image. It lights the floor.

The far end. The main image sits against the back wall, on a throne, usually with two attendant figures smaller and lower. Which buddha it is tells you whose monastery you are in: Shakyamuni in an old foundation, Tsongkhapa in a Gelug house, Padmasambhava in a Nyingma one. Page 8 of the statues book goes through the identification.

The near end. A raised seat for the abbot, usually empty during visiting hours, and a low table with the day's texts still open on it.

What the columns are wearing. Every column is wrapped in cloth — a skirt at the base, a hanging banner from the capital, sometimes a painted beam across the top. The cloth is changed for festivals, and the hall is judged by how new it looks.

What is on the walls. Not plaster. Either paint applied straight onto the wall, or thangkas hung from a rail near the ceiling. Page 9 is about the difference.

08  —  The walls

The walls are the library

For most of their history these monasteries had no printed books to speak of. What they had was wall. The inside of a Tibetan hall is covered from the floor to the beams, and the covering is not decoration — it is the teaching, laid out in an order you can walk along.

Two techniques, and they mean different things. A fresco is painted straight onto prepared plaster and cannot be moved. A thangka is painted on sized cloth, mounted in silk, and hung from a rail under the eaves — so it can be taken down, lent out, carried in procession, or replaced for a festival. The big fixed compositions are painted. The precious, portable, or seasonally changed ones are thangkas.

What the colour is made of. Blue from lapis carried over the mountains, red from cinnabar, green from malachite, gold beaten to leaf. Ground with glue and laid on plaster, these hold their colour for centuries — which is why an old wall can still look lit from inside.

What is on them, roughly in the order you meet it. Near the door, protectors — fierce, dark, and deliberately unpleasant. Then the life of the buddha, in panels. Then his previous lives. Then the line of teachers who brought the tradition to this particular house, which is the wall's real argument. Then mandalas, and finally rows of small identical buddhas filling whatever wall is left over.

Hands off, and ask first. Paint on plaster does not survive being touched, and flash does not help it. In most halls photography without flash is tolerated; in the old assembly halls and in anything dark, ask. A monk saying no is the normal answer and not a judgement about you.

Do not read the walls as a story. They are read clockwise, and the order was set by the abbot who paid for them. Two monasteries of the same school will give you the same figures in a different sequence. The one fixed point is the lineage wall: if you want to know whose house you are standing in, find the row of portraits and read the names at the bottom.
09  —  The altar

What is on the table

A Tibetan altar is not a display case. It is a working surface, and what is on it changes from day to day and from chapel to chapel. These eight are the ones you will see almost everywhere, roughly in order of how often they turn up.
Five-colour grain
五色米
Barley or rice dyed five colours and heaped into a cone in a bowl. The colours stand for the five buddha families. The grain is also what the place lives on.
Barley beer
青稞酒
In small bowls, and offered to protectors far more often than to buddhas. It is not a symbol of a drink. It is the drink, and it gets poured out.
Butter lamp
酥油灯
A cup of clarified butter with a wick, in rows along the front of the altar. In most rooms this is the only light there is, and the offering visitors are asked to sponsor.
Silk scarf
哈达
White, unhemmed, often blue when given to a protector. You offer it open on both palms. It comes back folded round your neck, or it stays draped on the image.
Prayer beads
念珠
A hundred and eight beads, left on the altar when a pilgrim has finished a retreat, or by a family for a monk to use. They are working tools, not jewellery.
Money
钱币
Notes folded and pushed under the altar cloth, or laid in the lap of the image; coins in a bowl. Nobody counts it while you are standing there, and you are not expected to give much.
Jewellery
金银首饰
Rings, earrings, chains, left at a shrine with a reputation for answering prayers — usually a protector's chapel or a Tara's, and usually by women. It is given, not stored.
Torma
朵玛
Barley flour and butter, moulded into a cone and painted red or white. Not food for a buddha: a torma is a substitute, offered in someone's place, and thrown out afterwards.

The one rule that covers all of it. Nothing on the table is there for you to handle. You may be handed a scarf to place, or a lamp to light; you will not be invited to pick anything up. If you want to give money, put it down flat and do not wait for change.

What is missing. No flowers, no fruit, no incense burning in front of the image in most halls — the smoke is outside, in a censer in the yard. Tibetan altars are built out of what keeps a body alive at altitude: grain, butter, beer, and cloth.

10  —  The dark room

The room with no windows

Somewhere off the hall — usually beside the entrance, sometimes directly behind the main image — there is a small room with a low door and no window at all. The most powerful figure in the monastery is in there, and it is almost never the one you came to see.
1A door you have to duck through. Small on purpose. You enter it the way you enter a house in a village: head down, one step, no ceremony.
2The protector, not a buddha. This chapel belongs to one figure, usually a wrathful one — Mahakala, Palden Lhamo, a local mountain god with a temper. It belongs to the monastery, not to the school.
3A curtain in front of it. Often the image is veiled, and unveiled only for certain rituals. You may be in the room and still not see it.
4What is offered here. Barley beer, tormas, sometimes meat, sometimes black tea — the food of a household, not of an altar. This is a room you feed, not one you admire.

Why no window. A protector chapel is not built for viewing. The darkness is the setting the figure was designed for: you see a face and a pair of hands in lamplight and nothing else, and your eyes do the rest. The room is also the safest place in the building for objects that are not meant to be photographed, which is a practical reason as well as a religious one.

Do not confuse it with the vestibule. The first room you entered is public and brightly painted. This one is behind a curtain, off a corridor, and always the darkest room in the compound. If you have only one hour, spend it in the hall; if you have two, ask a monk whether the protector's chapel is open, and go in quietly.

What it smells like. Butter, barley beer that has turned a little sour, juniper smoke. There is no window, so none of it leaves. The smell is part of the room's reputation: it is the smell of a place that gets fed.

The rules are on the door. Some protector chapels ask women not to enter; some ask that no one enter during certain rituals. There will be a notice, in Tibetan and usually in Chinese, and it is not a suggestion. If the door is shut and a monk is standing outside it, the answer is already no.

Who the protector is. Usually not a buddha and not a bodhisattva: a bound local deity, a mountain or a river or a former enemy of the doctrine, sworn to defend it. That is why the chapel is furnished like a house — it is a household you are visiting, and the household has a temper.

What is left on the table. Money, strings of beads, a ring, a bracelet — whatever people had on them. It is not a donation in the sense a museum would understand: it is a gift to a guest who is expected to notice. It is also not yours to touch, count or photograph.

11  —  Scale

Three sizes of the same plan

The courtyard plan scales without changing shape. A village monastery is one yard and one hall. A great monastery is a dozen yards, each with its own hall and kitchen and dormitories, sharing one enormous assembly hall — and the whole thing stacked up a hillside.
1
A village monastery One yard, one hall, twenty monks, one kitchen. The hall does everything: assembly, teaching, storage, and the winter's worth of butter. What you learn in an hour here is true of the biggest monastery in the country, only smaller.
2
A college — dratsang The unit a great monastery is actually built from. Each college has its own courtyard, its own assembly hall, its own kitchen and its own intake of monks from particular districts. Three colleges side by side is Sera. They share one great hall, and nothing else.
3
A hillside Drepung, Sera and Ganden were built up slopes, so the courtyards are terraces and the route between them is a staircase. The highest terrace usually holds the tantric college or the abbot's residence.

What a college actually owns. Its hall, its kitchen, its dormitories, its own protector, and its own intake of boys from a particular set of villages. Monks belong to a college the way a student belongs to a faculty, and the rivalry between colleges is older and sharper than any rivalry between monasteries.

The one building every monastery shares. The great assembly hall, where the whole body meets — on festival days, for ordination, and for the long prayers that run through the night. It is the only room in the compound that belongs to everybody, and the only one that is always bigger than it needs to be.

What never scales. The vestibule stays small, the protector chapel stays dark, and the altar stays a table. However big the monastery gets, the sequence from the gate to the image — yard, porch, hall, dark — stays exactly the same length.
12  —  Two plans

Two ways to arrange a buddha

A Chinese monastery runs on a single line. A Tibetan one runs on a single yard. Both are planned down to the last doorway, and the difference tells you what each tradition thinks a visitor should meet first.
Chinese Tibetan
Layout One axis, gate to library, halls in a row One yard, hall on the far side, buildings round the other three
Your route You walk through a sequence of halls You walk into a yard, then into one room, then another
The buddha Centre of the main hall, facing south, in daylight Far end of the hall, facing the door, in permanent shadow
The four kings A hall of their own, with a fat laughing buddha facing the gate Paintings on the side walls of a porch; no hall, no fat buddha
Circumambulation No route built into the plan; you walk through, not around Built in: the hall, the reliquary, the whole compound are walked clockwise
Roof Pitched, tiled, with upturned eaves Flat, with a parapet, and a gilded pavilion over the main image
Light Windows and a bright interior One roof lantern; everything else is lamplight

What the Chinese plan argues. That the teaching is a sequence, and that you should be carried through it in order, the way an emperor would be received: defences, then guardians, then the throne, then the text. The building is a sentence with a beginning and an end.

What the Tibetan plan argues. That the teaching is a place, and that you should enter it and turn around inside it. The yard is the world, the hall is the teaching, and the dark room is what the teaching is for. Nothing tells you where to stop.

13  —  At the door

Ten things to know before you go in

None of this is obscure, and none of it is enforced by anyone except the person standing next to you. But a monastery is a workplace first and a monument second, and these ten are the ones that actually matter.
1
Walk clockwise. Round the hall, round the reliquary, round the whole compound. Keep the building on your right. The one exception is a Bon monastery, which goes the other way — if the symbols are swastikas turning counter-clockwise, follow the crowd.
2
Take your hat off before you cross the threshold, not after.
3
Step over the threshold. It is a beam, sometimes knee-high, and standing on it is the one thing that will get you a sharp look.
4
Do not point at an image with one finger. Gesture with an open palm, or with your chin.
5
Touch nothing. Not the statues, not the books on the altar, not the tormas, not the instruments. A monk will hand you what you are meant to hold.
6
Ask before you photograph, every time. Most halls forbid it; some allow it for a fee; a few allow it and then ask you not to publish. The protector chapel is always no.
7
Read the notice on the dark room. Where it says women may not enter, that is the rule of that monastery, and arguing it is not a conversation you can win.
8
Never step over a monk's seat, a text, or a ritual object lying on the floor. Walk round it, even if it takes you across the room.
9
Give flat, and do not wait for change. Money goes down on the altar or into the box. Nobody will count it, and nobody will give you a receipt.
10
At a debate, stand still and to one side. The pairs are working; walking between them is like walking through someone's sentence.
The one that is not on the list. If a ritual is under way — drums, long horns, rows of monks with texts — you may stand at the back and watch, and you may not walk through the rows to get a better angle. The ceremony is not a performance with an audience; you are in someone's working day.
14  —  Words

Words, and where this came from

The Tibetan terms below are the ones you will see on signage, spelled the way the signs spell them. None of them is necessary to enjoy a monastery. All of them make the second visit better than the first.
gompa monasteries. Literally a remote place.
lakhanga chapel or shrine room, smaller than a hall.
dukhangassembly hall of a college or a small monastery.
tsokchenthe great assembly hall of a whole monastery.
dratsanga college: the unit a large monastery is built from.
khamtsena hostel inside a college, for monks from one district.
labrangthe residence and estate of a reincarnate lama.
gonkhangthe protector's chapel: dark, small, usually restricted.
chortena reliquary mound; the Tibetan form of a stupa.
korathe circuit round a monastery or a sacred hill.
thangkaa painting on cloth, mounted in silk, hung from a rail.
pechaa loose-leaf scripture, wrapped in cloth and stacked flat.
tormaa cone of barley flour and butter, offered and then discarded.
khataa white silk scarf given as an offering.
changbarley beer, offered to protectors.
khemarbarley flour mixed with butter and sugar; also the five-colour grain offering.
sangjuniper or pine burnt as an offering, usually in the yard.
tulkua recognised reincarnation, the occupant of a labrang.
khenpoa senior teacher, roughly a professor of doctrine.
rinpoche"precious one": a title for a lama, not a rank.
shamatacalm abiding: the basic sitting practice, taught first everywhere.
mandalaa circular diagram of a buddha's realm, painted, built, or offered.
chammasked ritual dance, performed in the courtyard at festivals.
gutorthe year-end ritual, in the last days of the Tibetan year.
losarthe Tibetan new year, the one week when every monastery is full.
How this was put together

The plan, the sequence of rooms and the contents of the altar are taken from what the buildings themselves show, and from the explanations Tibetan monks give visitors repeatedly, in the same order, in every monastery that receives them. Nothing here is drawn from a single building: the point is the pattern, and the pattern is remarkably stable.

Two cautions

Individual monasteries differ, sometimes sharply: a protector chapel may be upstairs, the vestibule may be a separate porch rather than a room, the main image may be behind glass. Where this guide and the building disagree, the building is right. And the rules at the dark room are local rules — read the notice, not the book.

Samantha
guest notes  ·  thirteenth in the series
Part Two  ·  造像

Faces in the Dark

藏传佛教造像辨识
01  —  How to read one

Six slots, filled in a fixed order

A Tibetan statue is not a portrait. It is a set of instructions in a fixed grammar, and the grammar is the same in every monastery from Lhasa to Kangding. Learn six slots and you can name most of what you will walk past.
123456
1Colour. A code, not decoration. White for the centre and for compassion; blue for the mirror that does not distort; yellow for increase; red for control; green for action; black for protection. It is convention, not doctrine — the same figure changes colour between traditions, so treat colour as a hint.
2The hands. Right hand down over the knee, fingers touching the ground: the moment of enlightenment, calling the earth to witness. Both hands at the chest, thumb and forefinger joined: the first sermon. Both hands flat in the lap: meditation. Palm out, fingers down: generosity. Palm out, fingers up: do not be afraid.
3What is held. A thunderbolt, a bell, a sword, a book, a long-life vase, a skull cup, a lotus, a noose, a mongoose. This slot is the most specific and the least ambiguous: the object is usually enough on its own.
4Posture. Cross-legged and still; one leg down, ready to move; standing; dancing. Stillness is for teaching, movement for action.
5The head. Bare, with a top-knot: a buddha. A five-leaf crown and jewellery: a bodhisattva. Skulls and hair standing up in flames: a protector. A pointed hat: a lama — and the colour of that hat tells you the school before you read a single label.
6The seat. A lotus: awakening. A sun disc: emptiness. An animal, which may identify the figure by itself. A corpse: a protector, treading on the self.
The figure above is Amitayus, the buddha of long life: red, crowned, seated, holding a vase with the nectar of immortality. Every slot is filled, and every slot agrees.

What the grammar cannot tell you. Whether the statue is old, valuable or any good. Most of what stands in a Tibetan hall has been repainted, often several times; the colour you are looking at is usually twentieth-century, and sometimes the gilding is thinner than the clay under it. A figure that has been repainted badly can have its mudra quietly wrong.

And what it will not tell you either. Which school made it. The same Vajrapani stands in a Nyingma chapel, a Sakya chapel and a Gelug chapel. What changes between schools is not the figure but which figures get the big hall, and what the monks do in front of them — which is the subject of the four pages that follow the shared ones.

02  —  The map

Five ranks, and three bodies

Before the names, the filing system. Almost every figure in a Tibetan hall belongs to one of five ranks, and the rank decides how it is dressed, where it stands, and whether you are meant to be frightened of it.
Buddha  佛Enlightened, and finished with coming back. Robes, bare feet, no jewellery. The top-knot on the head is the one mark that never varies.
Bodhisattva  菩萨Enlightened, but has postponed the exit in order to help. Crown, necklaces, silk — a prince in a palace, which is what the word means.
Yidam  本尊A tantric deity taken as a meditation focus. Peaceful or ferocious, often in union with a consort, often with several heads and many arms. Not a god to be prayed to: a diagram of a state of mind, to be visualised until it is one’s own.
Dakini  空行母Female, and about movement: the energy that carries liberation. Dancing, bare, with a skull cup and a flaying knife. The Tibetan word means “she who moves in space”.
Protector  护法Not enlightened. A being bound by oath to defend the teaching, and therefore always fierce. Kept in the courtyard or the entrance hall, not the main shrine — a bouncer, not a guest of honour.
Three bodies  三身

Everything above is the third body. The other two are formless or nearly so. Dharmakaya — the truth-body, with no shape at all; when it is given one, it is Samantabhadra in the old school or Vajradhara in the new ones, deep blue, holding thunderbolt and bell at the heart. Sambhogakaya — the body of enjoyment, which is what all the crowned, jewelled, radiant figures are: they exist in pure lands, not here. Nirmanakaya — the body that appears in this world, which is Shakyamuni, and also, by extension, every recognised tulku.

What changes between schools

Not the shared figures — Shakyamuni, Tara, Manjushri and Avalokiteshvara belong to all four. What changes is the yidam a school keeps at the centre of its practice, and the protector it keeps at the door. That is the whole of the difference you can see, and it is why the four school pages in this booklet are mostly a page of lineage portraits with one or two fierce figures behind them.

A rough rule for the door: red walls and Padmasambhava — Nyingma. A row of consciously odd, white-robed teachers — Kagyu. Grey walls, red-white-blue stripes, and Hevajra — Sakya. Yellow hats — Gelug.

03  —  Everyone’s buddha

Shakyamuni, in three positions

The historical buddha is the one figure no school argues about. What varies is not who he is but which moment of his life the hands are showing, and that is the only thing you need to look at.
Shakyamuni, touching the earth
释迦牟尼 · 触地印
right hand down · the earth as witness
Shakyamuni teaching
释迦牟尼 · 说法印
both hands at the chest · the first sermon
Shakyamuni, meditating
释迦牟尼 · 禅定印
hands flat in the lap · the commonest Han form
Maitreya
弥勒 · 强巴佛
legs pendant · flask · stupa in the crown

The two hands that matter. Right hand over the right knee, fingers reaching down to touch the earth: the moment under the bodhi tree when he called the ground to witness that he had earned the seat. This is the commonest Shakyamuni in Tibet, and the one to look for first. Both hands at the chest with thumb and forefinger joined into a small circle: the first sermon, at Sarnath, setting the wheel turning — and very often there is a small wheel carved between the hands to make it unmistakable.

What is on him. A patchwork robe, usually orange or red, covering both shoulders or leaving the right arm bare. No crown, no necklace, no earrings. Bare feet, soles upturned. The top-knot — the ushnisha — is a bump of bone, one of the thirty-two marks of a great being, and in Chinese sculpture it is often covered by a knob or a small crown so that it reads as a bun rather than a deformity.

The third position is lying on the right side, head on a bolster, one arm along the body: the parinirvana, the death at Kushinagar. You meet it as a long reclining figure in a separate hall, almost never in the main shrine, and in Chinese temples it is usually enormous and painted.

Maitreya is the next buddha, still in the Tushita heaven, and is drawn as a bodhisattva rather than a buddha: crowned, jewelled, often with a small stupa in the crown. In Tibetan art he sits “European fashion”, both legs hanging down like a chair — the one seated posture in the whole repertoire that means about to arrive. He holds a flask of water in the left hand and a sprig of nagakesara in the right. Remember that flask: it is the reason the Chinese Maitreya looks nothing like him, as page 21 shows.

04  —  The five families

One mandala, five gestures

The five tathagatas are not five different buddhas so much as one enlightenment seen from five sides. Every tantric mandala is built around them, and every fierce deity is a member of one of their families. If you learn one table in this booklet, learn this one.
Vairocana
毗卢遮那 · 大日如来
white · centre · lion
Akshobhya
阿閦佛 · 不动佛
blue · east · earth-touching
Ratnasambhava
宝生佛
yellow · south · palm down
Amitabha
阿弥陀佛
red · west · meditation
Amoghasiddhi
不空成就佛
green · north · palm up
ColourHandsVehicleClearsDirection
Vairocana 毗卢遮那whiteteaching, or fist at the heartliondelusioncentre
Akshobhya 阿閦blueright hand to the groundelephantangereast
Ratnasambhava 宝生yellowright palm out, fingers downhorsepridesouth
Amitabha 阿弥陀redboth hands flat in the lappeacockcravingwest
Amoghasiddhi 不空成就greenright palm out, fingers upgarudaenvynorth

The logic of the table. Each family owns one of the five poisons, one of the five aggregates, one of the five wisdoms, one direction and one colour, and the five line up in the same order wherever you meet them — on a mandala, on the ceiling of a hall, on the crown of a large statue. Learn the colours left to right and you can read a mandala you have never seen.

Where the sources disagree. Two slots in this table are not stable. Vairocana’s hand is either the teaching gesture or a fist with one finger raised, depending on which mandala the sculptor was following; and Amoghasiddhi’s vehicle is given as a garuda in most Tibetan lists but as a kalavinka, a bird with a human head, in some Indian ones. Neither is a mistake. Treat the colour and the direction as fixed, the rest as family resemblance.

05  —  Long life, medicine

The two red buddhas, and the blue one

Three figures get their own chapel in almost every Tibetan monastery, because they are the ones people ask for: length of life, and health.
Amitabha
阿弥陀佛 · 无量光
robes, bare head · meditation · the pure land
Amitayus
无量寿佛
crown · long-life vase · the same being
Bhaisajyaguru
药师佛 · 药师琉璃光如来
lapis blue · myrobalan in the right hand · bowl in the left

Amitabha and Amitayus are the same being. The names mean “infinite light” and “infinite life”, and the difference is entirely in the costume. Amitabha is shown as a buddha: robes, bare head, hands in meditation, no ornaments — the figure of the pure land. Amitayus is shown as a bodhisattva: crown, jewellery, silk, and a long-life vase held in both hands in the lap, filled with the nectar of immortality. Same red, same family, different slot. When a Tibetan family commissions a statue for a sick parent, it is Amitayus, not Amitabha.

The giveaway is the vase: a narrow-necked flask with a sprig or a small figure emerging from the top. If the hands hold a vase, it is long life. If the hands hold nothing and lie flat, it is the pure land.

Bhaisajyaguru, the Medicine Buddha, is deep blue — lapis, the colour of the stone ground for the pigment — and his two hands do different things. The right rests on the knee, palm out, holding the stem of a myrobalan plant with three lobes of fruit; the left lies in the lap holding a bowl or a jar of medicine. He is usually not alone: seven companion buddhas sit with him, and twelve yaksha generals stand guard. A blue figure with a plant in one hand and a bowl in the other cannot be anything else.

A note on the pill. The myrobalan — haritaki — is the base of most Tibetan medicine, and its three-lobed fruit is drawn rather than carved on small statues, which is why on a worn figure the right hand looks empty.

The thirty-five

In the older Chinese and Tibetan confession liturgies there are thirty-five buddhas, of whom Shakyamuni is the thirty-fifth, arranged in a long row for the purifying practice of prostration. They are distinguished by hand gestures alone and even specialists argue about the order. You will see them as a wall of small identical gilt figures — that is the point; they are a crowd, not portraits.

The thousand buddhas

The same logic taken further: this world-age is said to produce a thousand buddhas, of whom Shakyamuni is the fourth. Painted in rows across the walls of a hall, they are usually identical, and repainted so often that the older layers show through at the edges of the robes.

06  —  Avalokiteshvara

One bodhisattva, four bodies

Compassion has more forms than anything else in the pantheon, and Tibetans count them in the hundreds. Four of them account for nearly every statue you will see.
Shadakshari
四臂观音
white · four arms · jewel at the heart
Ekadasamukha
十一面观音
eleven heads in three tiers · Amitabha on top
Sahasrabhuja
千手千眼观音
a thousand arms · an eye in every palm
Hayagriva, the fierce form
马头明王
red · horse head in the hair · one finger raised

The four-armed one is the default. White, seated, wearing the silk and jewellery of a prince, with the first pair of hands joined at the heart around a wish-granting jewel and the second pair holding a crystal rosary on the right and a white lotus on the left. The six syllables — om mani padme hum — are his, and this is the form the Dalai Lamas are said to embody. If a white figure has four arms and a jewel at the chest, stop looking.

Eleven heads is the response to a specific story: his head split into eleven pieces from grief at the suffering he saw, and Amitabha put it back together as eleven, in three tiers, so he could hear every cry in every direction. Count the tiers — three rows of three, plus one wrathful head, plus Amitabha on top — and you have the figure.

A thousand arms is the same story pushed to its end: the arms fan out into a circle, each palm with an eye, and the whole thing reads less as a body than as a radiating diagram of attention. Usually gilt and standing, usually behind glass, usually with the two principal hands joined at the chest.

Hayagriva is the fierce form, and looks nothing like the others: red, bulging eyes, a green horse’s head rearing out of the hair, flames, and one finger raised in a threat. He belongs with the protectors, and is the one Avalokiteshvara you are meant to be startled by. In the old school he is one of the eight great herukas; in the Gelug he is a protector of the teachings on Avalokiteshvara himself.

The Chinese Guanyin is the same being, and takes a different route entirely — see page 21.

07  —  The three protectors

Wisdom, practice, power

Three bodhisattvas stand for the three things a practitioner needs, and in Chinese temples they flank the main buddha as a set. Only one of them is usually fierce, and that is the one worth recognising at a distance.
Manjushri
文殊菩萨
sword and book · lion · wisdom
Samantabhadra
普贤菩萨
six-tusked elephant · the bodhisattva of practice
Vajrapani
金刚手菩萨
thunderbolt · blue and fierce · power
Samantabhadra, the primordial buddha
普贤王如来
blue · naked · in union · the old school only

Manjushri carries a sword in the right hand and a book on a lotus in the left. The sword is not for people: it cuts through ignorance, and it is always shown with flames along the blade, because what it cuts is not a thing but a mistake. The book is the Prajnaparamita, the sutra on the perfection of wisdom. Yellow-orange skin, a lion under him, and the sword raised — the single most recognisable bodhisattva in Asia. His fierce form is Yamantaka, on page 16.

Samantabhadra is the bodhisattva of practice, the one who does rather than knows, and rides a six-tusked elephant. In a Chinese hall he is the right-hand attendant of Shakyamuni, with Manjushri on the left.

Vajrapani holds a thunderbolt and is blue and muscular and, in Tibet, usually wrathful: flames, a tiger skin, a third eye. He is the power that removes obstacles, and he is the oldest of the three as an attendant figure — he appears in the earliest Indian reliefs as the buddha’s bodyguard, a thunderbolt-bearing yaksha, and only later becomes a bodhisattva.

A trap worth knowing. Samantabhadra the bodhisattva (普贤) and Samantabhadra the primordial buddha (普贤王如来, Kuntuzangpo) share a name and nothing else. The bodhisattva is an elephant-riding figure in silk; the primordial buddha is deep blue, naked, unadorned, seated in union, and belongs only to the old school, where he is the dharmakaya itself. If it has no clothes and no ornaments, it is not the one with the elephant.

08  —  Tara

The one who saves, in twenty-one colours

She is the most popular figure in Tibetan Buddhism after Avalokiteshvara, and the one with the best story: a princess who was told she could not reach enlightenment in a woman’s body, and vowed to do it as a woman anyway.
Green Tara
绿度母
green · right leg down · blue lotus · action
White Tara
白度母
white · seven eyes · legs folded · long life
Kurukulla
咕噜咕咧佛母
red · flower bow and arrow · one of the twenty-one

Green Tara is the one in a hurry. Her right leg is extended, foot on a lotus, as though she has been interrupted while getting up to leave; the right hand is open, fingers down, granting; the left is at the chest with thumb and forefinger joined, holding the stem of a blue lotus that opens at her ear. Green means action, and the leg means now. She is the one people pray to when something is actually happening.

White Tara is the opposite temperament: both legs folded, still, and seven eyes — two in the face, one in the forehead, and one in the palm of each hand and the sole of each foot. Those extra eyes are for long life, and she is invoked for exactly that, usually alongside Amitayus.

The twenty-one are twenty-one versions of the same vow, differing by colour, mood and what the hands are doing — white for peace, yellow for increase, red for attraction, black for the removal of fear. A wall of twenty-one small Taras, each slightly different, is a standard commission, and reading them is an exercise in exactly the six slots on page 2.

How to tell Tara from a bodhisattva at a glance: the left hand at the chest holding a flower stem, and the flower is what identifies her — blue lotus for Green Tara, white for White Tara. Without the flower it might be any crowned female figure; with it, it is her.

Tara is the one major figure whose gender was, in the story, the point. The vow is recorded in the Manifestation of the Tathagata sutra and is the reason she is invoked by women in particular.

09  —  Nyingma  ·  宁玛派

The old school, and the man who came from Oddiyana

The Nyingma are the only school that traces itself to the first transmission, in the eighth century, before the great translations. Their statues look older because they are organised around a person rather than an institution.
Padmasambhava
莲花生大士
red lotus hat · thunderbolt · skull cup · trident
Yeshe Tsogyal
益西措嘉
white dakini · trident and skull cup
Samantabhadra, the primordial buddha
普贤王如来
blue · naked · the dharmakaya given a body
Vajrakilaya
普巴金刚 · 金刚橛
three faces · wings · the dagger

Padmasambhava — Guru Rinpoche, “the precious teacher” — was invited from Oddiyana in the eighth century to subdue the local powers and to build Samye, the first monastery in Tibet. He is drawn almost always in the same way: seated, right leg slightly out, a red lotus hat with folded flaps and a sun and moon on the front, a thunderbolt in the right hand, a skull cup in the left, and a trident staff leaning at his shoulder. Eyes wide open, moustache fine. He is not a buddha in the canonical sense and is never dressed as one.

The eight names are eight episodes in his life, each with its own costume — as a prince with a turban, as a monk, as a tantric yogin in a tiger skin, as a wrathful figure with a dagger. A set of eight paintings or statues in a row is this, and the differences are all in the sixth slot.

Yeshe Tsogyal, the woman who recorded what he taught and hid it for later discovery, is drawn as a white dakini with a trident staff and a skull cup, and is the school’s second founder in everything but name.

What is distinctive is the terma: teachings buried in the eighth century and found later by tertons, which is why the Nyingma pantheon keeps growing and why so many of its fierce deities are not in the other schools. Vajrakilaya — the dagger — is theirs above all: blue, three faces, wings, and a blade held in the right hand. Ekajati, one-eyed and one-breasted, is their guardian of the tantras. Neither appears in a Gelug hall.

10  —  Kagyu  ·  噶举派

A chain of five men, and one buddha above them

The Kagyu are the school of oral transmission: the teachings passed from ear to ear, which is what the name means. Their halls are full of portraits — not of deities, but of the people in the chain.
Vajradhara
金刚持
blue · thunderbolt and bell at the heart · the dharmakaya
Tilopa
帝洛巴
dark skin · no hat · a sesame press
Naropa
那洛巴
a scholar who gave it up · skull cup and staff
Marpa
玛尔巴
a heavy layman · dark robe · no hat
Milarepa
米拉日巴
thin, green from nettles · hand at the ear · singing
Gampopa
冈波巴
the doctor of Dagpo · teaching

The head of the chain is not a man but a body of enlightenment: Vajradhara, deep blue, holding thunderbolt and bell crossed at the heart, in jewelled robes. He is the dharmakaya in a form that can be carved, and he appears at the top of every Kagyu lineage painting.

Tilopa, an Indian mahasiddha, is drawn almost naked, dark, working at an oil press — the story is that he was set to press sesame oil as a servant and reached realisation doing it. Naropa is the scholar who gave it all up and was put through twelve ordeals; he is drawn with a skull cup and a staff, often with a dog.

Marpa the Translator brought it to Tibet in the eleventh century, and is drawn as a heavy, scowling layman in a dark robe — a farmer and landowner, not a monk. Milarepa is his greatest student, and the easiest figure in the whole pantheon to recognise: thin to the point of emaciation, greenish skin from years of living on nettles in caves, one hand cupped at his ear because he is singing. His cotton robe is the reason for the name “cotton-clad”. Gampopa, the doctor from Dagpo, merged the lineage with the monastic disciplines and founded the branch that produced all the rest.

Their fierce deities are the mother tantras: Chakrasamvara and Vajravarahi. And the two-arm Mahakala with a chopper and a skull cup, standing on a corpse, is the Karmapa’s own protector — the one that identifies a Karma Kagyu chapel.

11  —  Sakya  ·  萨迦派

Five patriarchs, three white and two red

The Sakya were a family before they were a school: one clan, the Khön, kept the teachings and the abbacy for nine hundred years. Their five founders are the most useful group portrait in Tibetan art, because the costume tells you which is which.
Sachen Kunga Nyingpo
萨钦 · 贡噶宁波
white robes · first of the three white
Sonam Tsemo
索南孜摩
white robes · the second patriarch
Drakpa Gyaltsen
扎巴坚赞
white robes · the third patriarch
Sakya Pandita
萨迦班智达
red robes, shaved head · first of the two red
Phags-pa
八思巴
red robes · preceptor to Kublai Khan
Hevajra
喜金刚
eight heads · sixteen arms · dancing

Three white, two red. The first three patriarchs were laymen: married, long-haired, in white robes, and they are drawn that way. The last two were monks, in red, with shaved heads. Once you know the rule you can name the group from the far end of the hall.

Sachen Kunga Nyingpo, the first, is the one who systematised the Lamdre, the “path and its fruit”: the teaching that the whole of the path is already contained in the result. Sonam Tsemo and Drakpa Gyaltsen are his sons and grandsons. Sakya Pandita, the fourth, was the scholar’s scholar — the title means “the pandit of Sakya” — and went to the Mongol court at Liangzhou in 1246 to negotiate the terms on which Tibet would submit, which is why a Tibetan abbot appears in Chinese history books.

Phags-pa, his nephew, went further: preceptor to Kublai Khan, imperial preceptor of the Yuan, and the designer of the script that bears his name. The Sakya ruled Tibet under Mongol protection for about a century, until 1351. It is this century that explains why a small town in Tsang has a library the size of a cathedral wall.

The walls are painted in vertical stripes of red, white and grey-blue — three of the school’s deities: Manjushri, Avalokiteshvara and Vajrapani. In Kham you will see the same stripes on the monastery at Dege, which is Sakya, and on the cliff at Gyantse.

The fierce deity here is Hevajra: eight heads, sixteen arms, four legs, dancing, and holding skull cups in every hand. Sakya keep him closer to the centre than any other school.

12  —  Gelug  ·  格鲁派

The yellow hats, and three fierce ones

The youngest school, and the one that governs. Founded in 1409 by a reformer from Amdo, it put the monasteries back under strict discipline and made scholarship the route to everything. Its statues are the easiest in Tibet to date: if it is yellow, it is Gelug.
Tsongkhapa
宗喀巴
yellow hat · sword and book at the shoulders · Manjushri’s attributes
Gyaltsab Je
贾曹杰
yellow hat · a book · the right-hand student
Khedrub Je
克珠杰
yellow hat · teaching · the left-hand student
Yamantaka
大威德金刚
nine heads · thirty-four arms · a buffalo’s head
Guhyasamaja
密集金刚
seated · six arms · blue
Chakrasamvara
胜乐金刚
four faces · twelve arms · on a corpse

Tsongkhapa is drawn in monk’s robes and a yellow pandita hat with the two ear-flaps folded up, hands at the chest turning the wheel of the teaching. Two lotus stems rise from his hands and open at shoulder height: on the right a sword, on the left a book — the attributes of Manjushri, because he is regarded as Manjushri in person. If you see a monk with a sword and a book flowering at his shoulders, it is not a bodhisattva. It is the founder.

His two students sit one on each side, and they are always a set of three: Gyaltsab Je on his right and Khedrub Je on his left, both in yellow hats, both holding books. The trio is called the “father and two sons”.

The three yidams behind them are what the school actually practises, and all three are fierce. Yamantaka, a buffalo-headed form of Manjushri, with nine heads and thirty-four arms, trampling a buffalo and a man: the destroyer of death. Guhyasamaja, blue, three faces and six arms, in union, holding thunderbolt, jewel, lotus, wheel, sword and bell. Chakrasamvara, four faces and twelve arms, in union, standing on a corpse.

Palden Lhamo, the pale-blue protectress on a mule, is the school’s particular guardian — and the only female among the eight great protectors. The Dalai Lama line belongs to this school, which is why the Potala is yellow.

Tsongkhapa’s tomb at Ganden was destroyed in 1966; the reliquary you see now is a reconstruction, and the monastery itself was rebuilt from almost nothing after 1980.

13  —  The fierce ones

Wrath is a function, not a mood

Every ferocious figure in a Tibetan hall is the fierce form of a peaceful one. Nothing here is a demon: the fangs belong to a being whose whole activity is to remove an obstacle, and the obstacle is inside you. Read the parts and the fear goes away — which is more or less the point.
123456
1Flames. Not hellfire: the fire of wisdom, burning what is mistaken. It always rises, never falls.
2Five skulls. Five, because there are five poisons — and a skull worn on the head means the poison has been emptied out and put on as ornament.
3The third eye. Sight into past, present and future at once. The bulging eyes are the same idea: nothing is being looked away from.
4Skull garland and tiger skin. Fifty-one skulls, for the fifty-one mental states; a tiger skin for impermanence. What is frightening has already been defeated.
5Many arms. Each hand holds something that cuts, binds, or pours. The count is not decorative: six arms is a specific deity, and the number is the fastest way to name it.
6The corpse or the animal underneath. Standing on a corpse means the self has been trodden flat. Standing on a buffalo means death itself is the vehicle.
Six-arm Mahakala — the protector the Gelug and the Dalai Lama line keep closest. Count arms: six means this one; two means the Karmapa’s; four means the older schools’.

Why they are kept at the door. A protector is not enlightened and is not a refuge. It is a being held by an oath, doing a job, and in a monastery it is placed where a guard would be: in the entrance hall, facing out, often behind a curtain that is opened only for ceremonies. Monks do not pray to them for their own sake; they are asked to clear the way.

The one thing to remember. The fierce figures are the same beings as the peaceful ones. Manjushri becomes Yamantaka; Avalokiteshvara becomes Hayagriva; the five buddhas become the five herukas. If you can name the peaceful form you can usually name the fierce one, because the family is the same — only the face has changed.

14  —  Protectors and dakinis

Four you will meet in the dark corners

The figures in the entrance hall and the side chapels are the ones nobody explains. Four of them account for most of what is behind the curtains.
Palden Lhamo
吉祥天母
dark blue · on a mule · an eye on its rump
Ekajati
一髻佛母
one eye, one tooth, one breast · a single flame of hair
Vajravarahi
金刚亥母
red · a sow’s head · skull cup and knife
Kurukulla
咕噜咕咧佛母
red · flower bow and arrow · attraction

Palden Lhamo is the only woman among the eight great protectors, and the most theatrical figure in Tibetan art. Dark blue, glaring, with a sun disc in the navel and a necklace of skulls, riding a mule across a sea of blood and fat. The mule has an eye on its rump: the story is that her husband shot an arrow at her and she pulled it out through the animal’s back. She is the guardian of Lhasa and of the Dalai Lama line, and the lake at Lhamo La-tso is named for her.

Ekajati is the guardian of the tantras in the old school: one eye, one tooth, one breast, dark blue, her hair standing up in a single flame. The single-ness is the point — undivided attention. She is not for beginners and is usually kept behind a curtain.

Vajravarahi is a dakini rather than a protector: red, dancing with one leg bent, a sow’s head emerging from the side of her own, a skull cup in one hand and a flaying knife in the other, a staff at her shoulder. She is the consort in the Chakrasamvara cycle and one of the two or three figures a Kagyu practitioner would know best.

Kurukulla is red, four-armed, and carries a bow and arrow made of flowers: the deity of attraction, and the only one here whose business is drawing things towards you rather than keeping them away. She is one of the twenty-one Taras, which is why she has a Tara’s crown rather than a protector’s skulls.

15  —  The arhats

Sixteen, or eighteen, and why nobody agrees

Along the two side walls of almost every large hall, in both traditions, there is a row of old men in monk’s robes. They are the only figures in the building who look like people, and the number of them changes when you cross a border.
Arhat with a jewel
阿罗汉 · 持宝
a monk’s robe · one attribute · an individual face
Arhat with a staff
阿罗汉 · 持杖
the same robes · the same seat · a different object
Arhat with a fan
阿罗汉 · 持扇
the fan is a Chinese addition · so is the hat

The sixteen are the disciples whom the Buddha asked to remain in the world until the teaching ended — not to teach, but to be present as witnesses. Their names and dwelling places come from a single Sanskrit text translated into Chinese in 654, and each one has a fixed attribute: one holds a mongoose, one a small stupa, one has his hands in meditation with his ribs showing.

The eighteen is a Chinese addition. From the tenth century, painters added two figures to the set, and because nobody could agree which two, the list changed repeatedly — a repetition of one of the sixteen, the author of the sutra, the Buddha’s own father. The Qianlong emperor settled it in the eighteenth century by fiat, naming the last two “the dragon-subduing” and “the tiger-subduing” arhat, titles that appear in no scripture. It stuck anyway.

Tibet has its own eighteen, and they are different again: the sixteen, plus Dharmatala — a layman with a load of books, usually drawn rather like a Chinese pilgrim — and Hvashang, the fat monk with a bag, who is the Chinese Budai. So a Tibetan hall may show sixteen or eighteen, and a Chinese hall shows eighteen almost always, and the two eighteens have only sixteen figures in common.

How to look at them. These are the only statues carved with individual faces: an old man with a broom, a man with a lion, a man with a fly-whisk, a man asleep. They are also the only ones where the sculptor was free, which is why the best portrait carving in a Tibetan monastery is often on the side walls rather than the altar.

In Chinese halls the eighteenth-century set is flanked by two more figures: the roaring lion and the boy who leads it. Nobody counts them.

16  —  The ones people ask for

Wealth, in five colours

There is a whole sub-pantheon of figures whose business is prosperity, and in a working monastery they are busy. Two are common enough that you will see them in any town temple.
Jambhala, yellow
黄财神
stout · a mongoose in the left hand · a lemon in the right
Jambhala, black
黑财神
the fierce one · naked · the same mongoose
Vasudhara
持世菩萨 · 财源天母
yellow · a sheaf of grain · a book and a vase

Jambhala comes in five colours — yellow, white, black, green and red — one for each of the five families, and the yellow one is by far the commonest. He is stout, pot-bellied, often fierce-faced, and sits or stands with a mongoose in the left hand and a lemon in the right. The mongoose is the giveaway: in Indian iconography it is the animal that brings treasure out of its mouth, and on every statue of him its jaws are open and jewels are falling out.

Why a mongoose. It is also the enemy of the snake, and a snake is what a naga is: the beings who hold wealth underground. The image is not subtle. He is usually shown with one foot on a conch shell and a garland of jewels, and in Tibetan halls he is very often in a side chapel by the door.

Vasudhara is the female counterpart: yellow, seated, and the only figure here whose hands are full of grain. She holds a sheaf of rice, a book, a vase and a jewel, and she is invoked for harvest and household wealth rather than business fortune. In Nepal she is far more prominent than in Tibet, and the two traditions draw her almost identically.

A note on what these are for. The wealth deities are not a licence to ask for money. In the texts the request is for the resources to practise — food, time, a place to sit — and the standard Tibetan comment on them is that a greedy person who propitiates Jambhala gets exactly what a greedy person deserves.

17  —  The furniture

Four objects that are not statues

Half of what is being venerated in a Tibetan hall is not a figure at all. These four are worth knowing because they are the ones you will be asked not to touch.
Stupa
藏 chorten · 塔
A diagram of the cosmos in five parts: a square base for earth, a dome for water, a cone for fire, a parasol for wind, a flame for space. There are eight standard shapes, one for each event in the Buddha’s life. Relics go inside the dome.
Mandala
dkyil ‘khor · 曼荼罗
A palace seen from above: four gates, four quarters, a centre. Painted on cloth as a support for visualisation, or offered as a plate of rice and metal rings. The circles are not decoration — each one is a boundary.
Prayer wheel
ma ni ‘khor lo · 转经筒
A cylinder of printed mantras. Turning it clockwise is held to be the same as reciting them, which is why the old women at the gate are walking in one direction and never the other. Big ones are turned by hand, small ones by water or by the wind.
Torma
gtor ma · 朵玛
Barley flour, butter and colour, moulded into a cone. An offering cake, painted red for the fierce deities and white for the peaceful ones. They are made fresh, left for days, and then put out for the birds.

And two more. A thangka is a painted scroll mounted in silk, and it is not a painting in the Western sense: it is a support for practice, painted to fixed measurements from a canonical handbook, in mineral colours that do not fade but do flake. The silk mount is part of the object, not packaging. A butter lamp is the standard offering, and the number of them in front of a figure is the most reliable sign of how important that figure is to the people who use the hall.

The one rule. Do not touch, do not point with one finger, and do not walk in front of the altar to photograph. In almost every Tibetan hall photography is either banned or charged for, and the ban is not about secrecy: the flash is what damages the pigment. If a monk is sitting in the doorway with a collection box, the fee is for the temple, not for you.

18  —  A Chinese temple

The building is the argument

A Han Chinese monastery is arranged on a single axis, and the sequence of halls is a course in doctrine: you are pushed through the defences, then the guardians, then the buddha, then the teaching, and only then the library. A Tibetan monastery is built sideways, around courtyards, and makes no such argument.
1山门, the gate. Three doors for the three ways of being released: emptiness, signlessness, wishlessness. Two muscle-bound guardians inside, one on each side, with a thunderbolt and a clenched fist. They are not kings and they have no names you need.
2天王殿, the kings. Facing you at the centre: a fat, laughing man with a cloth bag. That is Maitreya, or rather the tenth-century monk Budai, who was taken to be his incarnation — the single largest divergence between the two traditions, and page 21 explains it. Along the two walls, the four kings of the quarters; behind the fat man, facing the courtyard, the armed figure of Weituo.
3大雄宝殿, the main hall. The buddha, usually Shakyamuni with two disciples — an old man and a young one — or three buddhas: past, present and future, or the three bodies. Along the walls, the eighteen arhats. Behind the altar, facing the back door, a wall of painted rock and sea with Guanyin in the middle of it.
4法堂 and 藏经楼. Preaching, then books. The library is last because it is the least public, not because it is the least important.

Why the axis matters. The plan is Chinese, not Indian: a courtyard sequence borrowed from palace architecture, with the Buddha installed the way an emperor would be. The Indian stupa, which you walked around, is here pushed to the side or replaced by a pagoda outside the walls. You do not circumambulate a Chinese hall. You walk through it.

And the giveaway for a Tibetan visitor. A Tibetan monastery puts its assembly hall at the centre and its protector in a dark room off the entrance; the 佛像 are often in side chapels, and you may have to ask which door. In a Chinese temple everything important is on the line, in order, and you cannot get lost.

19  —  The Han pantheon

Six faces in a Chinese hall

Fewer figures, larger, and arranged in sets. The Chinese pantheon is a bureaucracy: everyone has a rank, a department and a fixed place, and almost nothing is wrathful.
Shakyamuni with two disciples
释迦牟尼 · 一佛二弟子
the old Kashyapa on the left, the young Ananda on the right
Guanyin
观音 · 观世音
white robe · a vase · female since the Song
Budai Maitreya
弥勒 · 布袋和尚
fat, laughing, a cloth bag · a tenth-century monk
A Heavenly King
四大天王
armour · one object · a pun about weather
Weituo
韦驮
armour · the thunderbolt says whether you may stay
Ksitigarbha
地藏菩萨
a monk’s robe · a staff and a pearl · the underworld

The four kings are the clearest case. Each holds an object whose Chinese name puns on a word for weather — a lute, a sword, a snake, an umbrella — so that the set reads as “may the wind and rain come in season”. This is pure Chinese wordplay and has nothing to do with Indian iconography. The northern king, Duowen, is the one exception: he carries a mongoose, because he is the same being as the Tibetan Jambhala.

Weituo is the general behind the fat buddha, and the most useful figure in the building for a traveller. The position of his thunderbolt is a coded notice: upright in the crook of his arm means the monastery can lodge travelling monks; resting on the ground means it cannot; raised means a night or two only.

Guanyin has been female since roughly the tenth century, and the change is Chinese, not Indian. The most common forms are the white-robed figure on a lotus, the “South Sea” Guanyin standing on a dragon’s head with a vase, and the thousand-armed version at the back of the main hall. A small figure of a child beside her is Sudhana, a pilgrim from a sutra, not a son.

Ksitigarbha is the one bodhisattva who is dressed as a monk — shaved head, robes, no crown — and holds a staff and a pearl. His department is the underworld, and his vow is not to become a buddha until it is empty. In a Chinese temple he has his own hall, usually dark, usually busy.

20  —  Two traditions

Same being, different body

This is the page worth keeping. Four figures cross the border between the two traditions, and in every case the identity is the same and the body is not. Once you have seen the pairs you can move between a Tibetan and a Chinese temple without losing your place.
TibetanChinese
Shakyamuni
Shakyamuni  释迦牟尼

Identical marks, different tailor. The Tibetan figure keeps the Indian patchwork with the right arm free; the Chinese one is dressed in a court robe and seated on a stone throne. Both touch the earth with the right hand.

Shakyamuni
Avalokiteshvara
Avalokiteshvara  观音

The largest change in the whole pantheon. In India and in Tibet he is a male prince with four arms and a jewel at the chest. In China, from about the tenth century, the figure becomes a woman in a white robe with a vase — probably through a fusion with a local goddess, and certainly through the story of the princess Miaoshan. The Chinese Guanyin has two arms and no jewel, and is far more popular than any buddha.

Guanyin
Maitreya
Maitreya  弥勒

Maitreya is a slender bodhisattva with a flask and a stupa in his crown, waiting in a heaven. Budai is a fat tenth-century monk from Fenghua with a cloth bag, whom a popular tradition identified as Maitreya’s incarnation. He is the first figure you meet in a Chinese temple and the last one you would connect with the Tibetan Maitreya.

Budai Maitreya
Mahakala
The protector at the door

Both do the same job and neither is enlightened. Mahakala is a wrathful deity bound by oath, black or blue, with skulls; Weituo is a Chinese general in armour with a thunderbolt. One is a demon tamed, the other a soldier promoted.

Weituo
TibetChina
DressIndian: one shoulder bare, patchwork robe, no jewellery on a buddhaChinese: both shoulders covered, a flowing court robe with a fold across the chest
HairA bare top-knot, sometimes with a small crownOften a knobbed bun, or a hood, or a crown pressed on top of it
SeatLotus, usually with a sun disc and a decorated plinthA stone or lacquered pedestal, often a lion throne, often with drapery
Fierce figuresEverywhere, and centralRare, and pushed to the door or the wall
SetsLineages: a row of teachersBureaucracies: four kings, eighteen arhats, twenty-four guardians
ColourPainted, mineral, colour is a codeGilt, stone grey, or polychrome with the colour as decoration
21  —  The key

Find it in thirty seconds

A dichotomous key, in the manner of a flower guide. Start at 1 and follow the number you are sent to. It will get you to a family, not always to a name — which, in a hall with two hundred statues, is enough.
1Fangs, flames, skulls, or a third eyego to 2
2… standing or dancing on a corpse, an animal, or a sun disc, in the entrance hall or behind a curtaina protector — p.14–15
3… seated in the main shrine, often in union, often with more than two armsa yidam — p.13
4Not fierce: a calm face, no fangsgo to 5
5… a pointed hat, and a human face with a personalitya lama — p.11–13; the hat colour is the school
6… no hat, a shaved head, monk’s robes, one odd objectan arhat — p.16
7… no hat, but a top-knot of hair or a crown, and jewellerygo to 8
8… a sword raised in the right hand and a book on a lotusManjushri — p.8
9… a lotus held at the chest, right leg downGreen Tara — p.9
10… a vase held in both hands in the lapAmitayus — p.6
11… four arms, a jewel at the chest, whiteAvalokiteshvara — p.7
12… a thunderbolt and a bell crossed at the chestVajradhara, or Vajrasattva — p.11
13None of the above: robes, no jewellery, a bare top-knotgo to 14
14… right hand over the knee, fingers downShakyamuni — p.4
15… both hands at the chest, a wheel between themShakyamuni teaching — p.4
16… both hands flat in the lap, red, no ornamentsAmitabha — p.6
17… a bowl of medicine in the left hand, a plant in the right, blueBhaisajyaguru — p.6
18… both legs hanging down, a flask in the left handMaitreya — p.4

When it fails. It will fail on the crowds: the thirty-five buddhas, the thousand buddhas, the rows of identical gilt figures that exist to be a crowd. Those are not meant to be told apart, and no label will help you. It will also fail on a badly repainted figure, where the mudra has been quietly got wrong — which happens more often than anyone likes to admit.

What to do then. Ask. A monk in a Tibetan hall will usually answer, and will usually be pleased; the names are not secret. What is restricted is the detail of tantric practice, not the identity of the figure — and if a question is declined, it is because the answer belongs to an initiation, not because you were rude.

22  —  Words

The vocabulary, briefly

Tibetan, Sanskrit and Chinese for the same things, because the labels in a monastery use all three at once and never explain the overlap.
TibetanSanskritChineseWhat it actually means here
sangs rgyasbuddha佛One who has woken up. Not a god, and not a creator.
byang chub sems dpa’bodhisattva菩萨Awake, but staying. “Enlightenment being.”
yi damishtadevata本尊A tantric deity used as a focus of practice; literally “mind bond”.
mkha’ ‘gro madakini空行母“She who moves in space.” Female energy, not a goddess.
chos skyongdharmapala护法Protector of the teaching. Bound by oath; not enlightened.
sprul skunirmanakaya化身The body that appears in this world; also a recognised reincarnation.
phyag rgyamudra手印A hand gesture. The most specific single clue on a statue.
rdo rjevajra金刚 · 杵“Diamond” and “thunderbolt” at once: what cannot be cut and what cuts.
dril bughanta铃The bell. Wisdom, always paired with the vajra’s method.
thod phorkapala颅器 · 嘎巴拉A skull cup. A bowl made of what is left over.
pad mapadma莲花Lotus. Awakening, and the reason half the names contain it.
chos ‘khordharmachakra法轮The wheel of the teaching; also the gesture of teaching.
mchod rtenstupa塔A reliquary, and a diagram of the cosmos.
dkyil ‘khormandala曼荼罗A palace seen from above; a circle of deities; an offering.
gtor mabali朵玛A moulded barley-flour offering cake.
bla maguru上师 · 喇嘛Teacher. Not a rank, and not a synonym for “monk”.
dge slongbhikshu比丘 · 和尚A fully ordained monk.
grub thobsiddha成就者Someone who has attained powers through practice; usually an oddity.
gter ma—伏藏A teaching hidden for later discovery. A Nyingma speciality.
sku ‘bum—佛像An image of a body; the ordinary word for a statue.
zhalmukha面Face. Used in the polite names of the fierce deities, who are “faces”, not demons.

Two traps in the vocabulary. “Lama” is not a synonym for “monk” — it means teacher, and a lama may be a layman. And “Tibetan Buddhism” is not one thing: the four schools disagree about which tantras are authoritative, what the ordination rules are, and who has authority over whom, and those disagreements are the reason two halls a hundred kilometres apart look so different.

The word for statue is worth knowing: sku, the honorific word for “body”. A statue is not a representation of a body; in the usage of the tradition it is a body, which is exactly why the consecration, the eye-opening ceremony, matters more than the carving.

23  —  Sources, and a note on method

What this is, and what it is not

These are diagrams. Every figure in this booklet is a line drawing of mine, built to show five things and nothing else: the gesture, the object, the body colour, the posture and the headdress. The proportions are simplified and the faces are not portraits. No photograph is reproduced anywhere, and no drawing is a copy of a particular statue — they are composites of the conventions.

Where the tradition disagrees with itself, so does this book. The mudra of Vairocana, the vehicle of Amoghasiddhi, the number of arhats, the date of the first Tibetan monastery: each of these has more than one authoritative answer, and the text says so rather than picking one silently. That is not hedging; it is the actual state of the material.

What I have left out. The entire subject of tantric practice: what the figures are for, what is visualised, what the initiations contain. That material is restricted by the tradition itself, and this booklet only describes what any visitor can see with their own eyes.

Iconography and identification. The two standard handbooks in English remain Alice Getty’s Gods of Northern Buddhism (1914, dated but still the clearest on attributes) and Antoinette Gordon’s The Iconography of Tibetan Buddhism. For the fierce deities, René de Nebesky-Wojkowitz’s Oracles and Demons of Tibet is the reference everyone cites, including for the inconsistencies.

Schools and history. Tucci’s Tibetan Painted Scrolls for the material culture; Snellgrove and Richardson for the outline; Kapstein for anything that needs to be right. On the Sakya and the Yuan relationship, the primary sources are the Liangzhou correspondence and the Phags-pa inscriptions.

Chinese material. The sequence of halls follows the seventeenth-century baizhang regulations as they settled into the modern formation; the eighteen arhats and the Qianlong settlement are documented in the standard Chinese Buddhist dictionaries and in the gazetteers of the individual monasteries.

Colour and measurement. Body colours, hand gestures and proportions follow the Samvara-class iconometric handbooks as summarised in the standard Tibetan drawing manuals; where a figure is built to a different system, the caption says so.

A note on the drawings

They were made as vector diagrams, not as paintings, so that each element can be changed independently and so that nothing is lost at the size they are printed. The niches behind the figures are drawn, not photographed — a Tibetan image is almost always made for a niche, and it seemed worth saying so.

If you want to go further

Stand in front of a figure for sixty seconds and fill the six slots on page 2 before you read any label. Then read the label. The gap between what you guessed and what it says is the whole of what this book is trying to teach, and it closes faster than you would expect — five or six figures in, and the grammar stops being foreign.

Samantha
Guest notes  ·  iconography

These two booklets were written for the vehicle, not for the shelf: 37 short chapters, drawn as diagrams rather than photographs, so that you can look at the page in a dark chapel and still recognise what is in front of you. Nothing in them is reproduced from a photograph, and nothing is for sale.